Feet Toward the Qibla: Is It a Sin?
What the Qurʾan, the hadith and the scholars say, and why we should be gentle with each other.
What we will cover
- The ruling at a glanceOne answer, one picture.
- Disliked or allowed?The two views among the scholars.
- Why is it disliked?The verse, the hadith and the reasoning.
- Be gentle, and avoid misunderstandingHow to treat others, and how to act wisely yourself.
- The schools’ own booksWhat the Hanafi and Hanbali books say.
Disliked, but not a sin
Qibla is the direction of the Kaʿbah, which Muslims face in prayer. Makruh means disliked: it is better to avoid, but the one who does it is not sinful.
Pointing the feet toward the qibla is makruh (disliked). It is not a sin.
There is no verse or hadith that speaks about the feet directly. The dislike comes from respect for the qibla, based on the Qurʾan and on hadith about the qibla.Scholars have two views
Neither view calls it a sin. They differ on one point: is it disliked, or simply allowed?
The two views among the scholars are shaded.
Disliked. It is better to avoid, out of respect for the qibla. This is the position written in the Hanafi books, and Hanbali scholars report it.
Allowed. There is no clear proof, so there is nothing wrong in it.
This guide follows the first view: it is disliked, because of the Qurʾanic principle of honouring what is sacred, and the hadith about the qibla. But because nothing in the Qurʾan or hadith speaks about the feet themselves, it is not a sin.
The verse, the hadith and the reasoning
The verse and hadith below do not mention the feet. Scholars compare: if the qibla must be respected in these cases, it should be respected here too.
Qurʾan Honouring what is sacred shows a God-fearing heart
Hadith The qibla must not be faced for these acts
Hadith A hadith that stresses it
So the scholars reason in three steps
The Qurʾan teaches us to honour what is sacred
Honour is a mark of a God-fearing heart (22:32).
The hadith protect the direction of the qibla
The Prophet ﷺ taught us not to face it for the toilet or to spit toward it. He gave this respect to the direction itself, not only to the Kaʿbah.
Custom and comparison
Pointing the feet at something is widely seen as a lack of respect. Scholars compare it with the cases in the hadith, and so call it disliked.
Do not judge. Be wise.
Do not call others sinners
In many Arab countries, sitting with the feet toward the qibla is very common. People do it without any thought of disrespect. Do not call them sinners or accuse them of bad manners.
Where it is seen as very disrespectful, avoid it
If you live where people feel strongly about this, do not do it. Do not do it to "prove a point". Guard your brothers and sisters from thinking badly of you.
The Prophet ﷺ cared about how things looked
Two Ansari men passed by while the Prophet ﷺ was walking with his wife Safiyya. He stopped them and said who she was, because he feared Shaytan would put an evil thought in their hearts.
What the Hanafi and Hanbali books say
Makruh to stretch the feet toward the qibla, in sleep or otherwise, when done deliberately. The reason given: it leaves out respect for the qibla, and it is bad manners.
Ibn Muflih reports the Hanafi view. He accepts it at the Kaʿbah itself. As a general rule, he says dislike needs proof, and that leaving it is probably better.